A man who erased his own phone with a GrapheneOS duress password at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport is now facing a federal destruction-of-property charge, in what observers call the first known US prosecution built on a phone’s duress feature. Samuel Tunick was pulled into secondary inspection by Customs and Border Protection on January 24, 2025, as he returned from the Dominican Republic. He is charged under Title 18, Section 2232(a), a statute that covers destroying property to prevent the government from seizing it. His lawyers appeared in federal court in Atlanta for the first time on Monday.
According to a defense filing drawn from the government’s own reports, CBP’s Tactical Terrorism Response Team opened the encounter by telling Tunick they were “looking for people who are pedophiles.” Officers never read him his Miranda rights. He said early in the interview that he did not want to keep talking without a lawyer and asked to call one repeatedly. Questioning continued. One officer told him his refusal to talk gave them authority to go through his phone. When he asked again about his attorney, an officer told him customs and immigration work was a different matter, “and we have search authority, we don’t need a warrant.”
What happened at the airport
Tunick eventually provided a password for his phone and his e-reader. The screen “went blank, flashed several times and the phone appeared to restart,” according to the government’s report. Officers seized the devices anyway and told him they would be returned after thirty days. A third officer took him to another room for an unrecorded pat-down. A DHS agent then told him he was free to leave once the other agents were finished with him.
The encounter had been coordinated in advance. An FBI Joint Terrorism Task Force officer and an FBI special agent had worked with CBP to question and search him on arrival. The government’s reports contain no indication that anyone suspected Tunick of carrying illegal images, his lawyers wrote. The reports do record interest in his association with Defend the Atlanta Forest, the movement opposing the clearing of the South River Forest for the Atlanta Public Safety Training Center. Opponents call the 85-acre, $115 million police facility Cop City. Federal documents label the movement an “Anti-Government, Anti-Authority Violent Extremist Group.” Tunick has not been charged with any offense connected to it.
How GrapheneOS duress works
GrapheneOS is a hardened Android build that replaces the stock software on Pixel devices. It lets an owner set a second PIN or password that irreversibly wipes the device and any installed eSIMs when entered at a credential prompt. No confirmation dialog appears, and entering it looks the same as a normal entry attempt.
How experts read the case
Bill Budington, senior staff technologist at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and Runa Sandvik, founder of the security firm Granitt, both said they had seen no comparable prosecution. Sandvik said she had discussed the scenario with activists and journalists for years and advised travelers to leave sensitive data off devices they carry across borders rather than count on wiping it. Christophe Boutry told the Guardian the prosecution “sends the message that [GrapheneOS] is criminal by default.” Matthew Dodge, an assistant federal public defender on Tunick’s legal team, said the statute is rarely seen in an indictment.
The legal arguments on both sides
Eleventh Circuit precedent favors the government. Its 2018 ruling in United States v. Touset permits forensic searches of electronic devices at the border with no warrant, no probable cause, and no individualized suspicion. Tunick’s lawyers cite decisions from the First, Fourth, and Ninth Circuits going the other way, including a Fourth Circuit holding that warrantless border searches of devices cannot be used to hunt for evidence of domestic crime. They also argue that surrendering a passcode is testimonial, relying on a 2012 Eleventh Circuit decision that decrypting and producing the contents of a hard drive triggers Fifth Amendment protection.
Courts allow suspicionless border searches to keep contraband out of the country. The accusation here is that data left a phone rather than entered the United States, and digital files move across borders over the internet anyway. A ruling on the motion is not expected before the end of October.
How Tunick was arrested
Tunick was arrested about ten months after the airport stop. His crowdfunding page says he was pulled over for a purported tail light fault and cuffed by FBI and DHS officers when he stepped out of the car. He has pleaded not guilty. The single-count indictment accuses him of acting to delete the digital contents of a Google Pixel to impair the government’s lawful authority to take it, in violation of Title 18 of what the document calls the “Untied States Code.”
FAQ
What is GrapheneOS?
GrapheneOS is a hardened Android operating system that replaces the stock software on Pixel devices. It adds security features including a duress password that irreversibly wipes the device and any installed eSIMs when entered at a credential prompt, with no confirmation dialog.
What is Samuel Tunick charged with?
Tunick is charged under Title 18, Section 2232(a) of the U.S. Code, a statute covering destruction of property to prevent the government from taking it. Prosecutors say he provided a password that deleted the contents of his Google Pixel instead of giving CBP access to it during a search at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on January 24, 2025.
Have there been other federal prosecutions over a phone duress wipe?
Bill Budington of the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Runa Sandvik of the security firm Granitt both said they had seen no comparable prosecution. The case is described as the first known US prosecution built on a phone’s duress password.
Want help with this in Myrtle Beach or Long Island? Talk to us.
NewSunSEO
Grow in Google and AI Search
AI-SEO, local search, paid ads and websites from one team, with offices on Long Island and in Myrtle Beach.
- AI-SEO
- Local AI-SEO
- AI Consulting
- PPC
- Web Design
- Web Development
- Long Island Office(631) 320-1700
- Myrtle Beach Office(843) 492-7131
Request a Free Proposal
Tell us about your business and where you want to grow.
We will reply by email to talk through your goals and what a proposal would include.
We use your details only to reply to you and send what you asked for. See our Privacy Policy.